The Shetland Bus

This is a ‘soap box’ posting. I’m just stepping up onto it now …

Available from Amazon

Available from Amazon

Dark winters provided the perfect cover for missions to occupied Norway during the Second World War, and the closest base was from Britain’s most northerly group of islands, Shetland.

Most Norwegians knew about the “Shetland Bus”, which did not go overland, but across the North Sea, taking supplies and saboteurs into the fjords under the noses of the Germans, and taking refugees to safety on the return journey – journeys in small fishing boats which covered thousands of miles, testing the skills of the Norwegian seamen who risked their lives in hurricanes, fog and darkness to make the crossing.

David Howarth was a junior naval officer who helped set up and operate the base. After the war he wrote a book “The Shetland Bus”, a story of successes and failures, and the courage, skill and adventurous spirit of the men who risked their lives on the Shetland Bus.

If you’ve not heard of this episode in World War 2 then I can thoroughly recommend David Howarth’s book. I’m not a huge fan of wartime stories (fact or fiction) but this one is special and worth reading. It can be ordered online from Amazon at £7.59, or from your local bookshop (ISBN-10: 1898852421), or I’m sure you could order it from your local library (check the online catalogue on their website!).

I am fortunate to have in my possession a first edition (1951) copy of the book. I have read it many times since it first came to my consciousness in the 1970s. And last month I wasparticularly looking forward to revisiting some of the sites associated with the wartime operation during our visit to Shetland last month, in particular Lunna and Scalloway. I rather think Marion was a bit bored with my telling of the story before our visit, but I believe she now shares my own enthusiasm that the tale should be remembered appropriately.

We were rather shocked at what we found in the way of remembering this unique story on the British side of the North Sea, particularly after completing a tour of Lerwick’s splendid new museum and archives at Hay’s Dock which brought together a unique collection of memorabilia which tells the story of Shetland over the centuries, but completely omitted any mention of The Shetland Bus (even in the WW2 exhibit).

So shocked, in fact, that I resolved to contact Shetland Amenity Trust (the local body responsible for preserving and promoting Shetland’s culture and heritage) to lament the lack of an appropriate commemoration in Lerwick and also to highlight that the presentation of such exhibits as are available for public viewing at Scalloway Museum are in a parlous state and, I fear, in danger of being lost if prompt action is not taken to preserve them for posterity.

Twelve days ago I sent an email to the general manager of the amenity trust, copied to the two Shetland Island Council nominated trustees and the Norway’s Ambassador to the UK offering a visitor’s perspective on the apparent disinterest (in Lerwick) of something that I feel deserves to be given a much higher profile.

On 8 May 1995, the fiftieth anniversary of V E Day, a commemorative memorial naming the Shetland Bus men was unveiled in Ålesund, Norway, by HRH Crown Prince Haakon.

Shetland emulated Norway a full eight years later. In 2003 a local body called the Shetland Bus Friendly Society, acting under the auspices of Scalloway Community Council, unveiled Shetland’s not-easy-to-find – and rather more modest – memorial in the village. Someone called Barbara Melkevik officiated. I don’t think she had an HRH monicker

Well, hats off to Scalloway Community Council and hurrah for their memorialisation, but even so it does seem a bit half cock compared to how Norway commemorated the wartime heroism doesn’t it? I mean, why wasn’t this initiated by Shetland Islands Council? Perhaps the community council got nowhere with the council when urging them to do something?

I can’t help feeling that the official Shetland “remembrance” of the wartime mission isn’t regarded with quite the same priority or feeling of Anglo-Norwegian fraternity that still holds in Norway.

I do feel very passionate about this heroic tale; I’ve been thinking of blogging about it since I sent my email. Today I decided to publish the text of my email for posterity’s sake.

“I should like to offer you some feedback on a recent visit I made to Lerwick and Scalloway Museums, which I hope you will receive in the warm spirit with which it is given: constructive rather than critical.

“I was most disappointed to find that the Shetland Bus story does not merit any form of mention in the (Lerwick) museum display areas. I looked very carefully and found nothing. I even enquired of museum visitor services staff in case I’d missed something less obvious – but they confirmed that there are no ‘bus’ exhibits at Lerwick with the singular exception of a model of a Norwegian fishing boat (the ‘Arthur’) at the foot of the staircase in the shop area.

“[A representative] from Visitor Services explained to my companion and I that the Scalloway Museum holds the Shetland Bus collection since Scalloway was the base for the wartime operation. Notwithstanding this, I found it rather peculiar that the islands’ principal museum, a landmark development indeed, made no mention of the Shetland Bus, particular in those exhibits that related directly to the last world war. This seems rather disingenuous to the memory of those who participated in the operation at a local level plus of course the many Norwegians who would have had Shetland connections during, and after, the German occupation of Norway, not to mention the souls who lost their lives during the ‘bus’ operation.

“Earlier the same day we had visited the Scalloway Museum with the explicit intent of seeing the ‘bus’ exhibition. I’m afraid we were rather shocked at the poor presentation and condition of many of the exhibits available to view. There were plenty of original items on display, available to touch. Many precious documents than cannot be replaced were looking – frankly – a bit moth-eaten and frayed at the edges. Such exhibits deserve much better preservation and presentation for the benefit of future generations. The museum staff at Scalloway were most welcoming and very friendly, but we left with the impression that they and the museum itself was a bit of a time warp; left behind by the 21st century. I don’t mean that in any insulting way to the individuals concerned – they clearly have a passion for the artefacts in their care, but I do question whether they have the right resources and skills to both preserve and present the history of Scalloway and the Shetland Bus to best effect.

“Our later visit to Hay’s Dock in Lerwick only accentuated what we had perceived to be really quite significant shortcomings at the Scalloway Museum. A comparison between the two establishments would not be favourable. [We were informed at Lerwick Museum] that there are plans afoot to redevelop Scalloway Museum, and we were heartened to learn this, but I am greatly concerned that swift action is required now to preserve the Shetland Bus memorabilia before it is too late.

“There were quite a number of Norwegians in Shetland last month for Johnsmas Foy. We couldn’t help wondering what they thought of the lack of representation at Hay’s Dock for the Shetland Bus; I’m sure some of these visitors must have known about the Shetland wartime operation (particularly those who had sailed across from Bergen) and have taken an opportunity to visit both Scalloway and Lunna during their stay. I can’t help but believe they would have been disappointed to see the way in which this important element of Shetland’s maritime history seems to have been pushed to one side.

The North Sea Monument in Ålesund

The North Sea Monument in Ålesund

“I should very much like to encourage you to find a way to present the Shetland Bus within the main museum in Lerwick in addition to the existing (or future) museum facility at Scalloway. It is such a wonderful story from the last war, very much a secret wartime operation (not unlike the Bletchley Park/Enigma story in many ways), and I believe that much could be done to improve the telling of the tale to future generations.

“But I believe the most pressing thing is to preserve the memorabilia on display at Scalloway to save it for posterity; it really is quite tragedy that’s unfolding there, and I’d like to ask you please to do something about it. I care for its well-being and I think that many Norwegians will do so too. In the darkest days of WW2, ordinary Norwegians knew that fishing boats were making dangerous journeys across the North Sea on their behalf. That kind of historical connection between Shetland and Norway is well worth celebrating and preserving properly.

“If you can find a way to marry the two museums together to present the ‘bus’ more appropriately I should certainly wish to return and see it for myself.

“Finally, the Shetland Bus memorial on the harbour-side in Scalloway is a lovely monument, but not very easy to locate if you don’t know where it is. I think Scalloway would benefit from a brown tourist sign pointing the way to the memorial!

“I hope you will find this feedback of some use in your exhibit and museum development planning.”

I’d be interested to know what you think of the above. Don’t hold back! If I’m wrong, then please tell me so.

I’m feeling a bit giddy now, so I’m stepping down off my soap box …

Advertisements

25 thoughts on “The Shetland Bus

  1. Pingback: Name a book with a strong setting « John Fox (X333XXX)

  2. Yes, I like the heritage hub concept. It’s a great idea, and provided it works in practice, extremely inclusive. Hats off to Shetland I say!

  3. It is an interesting idea, but it mustn’t suck everything inwards, including a lot of funding that might have gone to improve the Little Gems of the museum world.
    What is The Garrison landlady? Do you have soldiers billeted in Millport? Awfully good for the George St business😀

  4. The heritage hub is an interesting idea though, don’t you think? Of course, in Millport there is no blasted hub to spin visitors off to other bits of the island to visit things. All the current money is going to The Garrison, and it’s a pretty poor show!!

  5. You didn’t want…to…to…offend…I’m gobsmacked…the controversial Mr Fox?😆

  6. I did rather think that you had possibly got the wrong end of cat litter tray (as it were) when you asserted that it had been done, but didn’t want to offend!

    You can order fingerless Fair Isle gloves from the Spiders Web in Lerwick, they do mail order. Just Google ‘spiders web lerwick’ for their website. It’s a lovely shop.

  7. Which just goes to show you can’t expect things to happen quickly!😀 We thought it had already been done!
    Fpu bought a ridiculously cheap pair of Fair Isle fingerless gloves…and lost them…:cry…they matched the car. How cruel is the foul fickle paw of f***ing fate…
    Keep your soapbox dusted down Mister Fourex!

  8. I’m delighted to report that today I received a reply to my email from the general manager of the Shetland Amenity Trust. He wrote:

    “Thank you for your e-mail of 17th July outlining your concerns about the way in which the Shetland Bus story is currently told here in Shetland and my apologies for the delay in replying.

    “As you have yourself gathered, and indeed referred to in your e-mail, plans are well developed to relocate the Scalloway Museum to new premises and a major part of that will be the redevelopment of the displays and the telling of the Shetland Bus story which is so central to the history of Scalloway and Shetland. The need for a new museum in Scalloway has been identified for many years and it is heartening that this is now going to be a reality. All our efforts and resources are being directed to realising this new facility, rather than dissipating existing resources on the existing inadequate facilities in Scalloway, which you have noted and commented on.

    “Regarding the Shetland Museum in Lerwick, it was recognised at a very early stage that, due to space constraints, we would not be able to tell all the stories pertaining to Shetland’s natural and cultural heritage within the facility and, therefore, a policy decision was taken not to cover stories such as ‘The Shetland Bus’ which would be told much better at other local facilities throughout the islands. This serves the 2-fold objective of optimising our finite resources whilst at the same time ensuring that our heritage hub concept works as a practical reality to encourage visitors to go out to the local museums and interpretive centres to engage with the special stories relating to particular locales. An excellent example of this is that we know that the vast majority of visitors to Shetland come to see Shetland’s wildlife and, in particular, seabirds yet there is little or no information within the Shetland Museum on this. This is quite deliberate as it would be both wasteful and a poor substitute for visitors going to our premier seabird sites, such as Sumburgh Head, Hermaness and Noss, to see the birds at first hand. The same applies to the Shetland Bus story.

    “In conclusion, I reiterate that the Shetland Bus story is an important part of our heritage and I am certain that it will play its full role once the new museum in Scalloway opens its doors. In the meantime, I confirm that the Shetland Bus is incorporated into our interpretive panels at Lunna and Kergord, featured in our geographic leaflets and will also be a key component of our new trail leaflet on the islands’ wartime remains.

    “Yours sincerely,
    etc”

    and my acknowlegement:

    “Thank you very much for your most informative reply to my original message. I am considerably heartened to learn of your plans for Scalloway and the ‘bus; particularly to know that all is in hand and will be cared for appropriately.

    “I wasn’t aware previously of the heritage hub concept per se, though we did – I think – encounter something of this when visiting the Unst Heritage Centre which is most impressive. The kindly lady who was in sole charge on the Sunday we visited Haroldswick was extremely knowlegeable, and very welcoming.

    “My partner was particularly taken with the knitwear exhibits and the methods use to display them and spent an enjoyable fifteen minutes or so discussing the knitting method with the attendant who was clearly delighted to have a fellow knitter from outwith the islands enjoying the particular display.

    “I shall look forward to being able to return to visit the new Scalloway Museum in the fullness of time.”

  9. Of course we’ve visited the new Museum Mister Fourex. We met ruthodanort in the caff by accident and there was a power cut and fpu’s brother thought she and Ruth were wearing the same colour jumper on purrpose, like a sort of IB uniform😆
    We like the contrast between the Scalloway and Shetland Museums. The old museum on the Hillhead was definitely past its sell-by date, but at least they haven’t pulled it down like the contemporaneous swimming pool!
    Anyway, I thought the Scalloway Museum was in the process of being refurbished last time the pu’s visited.

  10. Fair enoughski KC. But I wonder if you’ve seen the new building at Hay’s Dock? I remember the old Shetland Museum next to the council offices – if that was still the principal museum then I’d not have got on my soapbox.

    A comparison between the (new) Lerwick and (old) Scalloway heritage venues is stark indeed.

  11. (Parental units both lived in Shetland for several years in the seventies.)
    We’ve always loved the Scalloway Museum’s presentation of the Shetland Bus story and found it purrfectly adequate. After all, Scalloway is the appropriate place for it, given the history.
    Pu’s met one of the Norwegians who had been involved in SB operations outside the Castle Chippy some years ago, a very modest old man who also very much appreciated Scalloway Museum’s excellent archive and display.
    I see no reason whatsoever for the soapbox on this one Mister Fourex.

  12. yes thats a good idea! Also does Shetland have a S1 community website ? If so you could leave a copy of your email there.It might touch the local community’s interest.- presumably there are still people alive there that have first hand knowledge of “the bus”

  13. I think I came across this story from “Arnish” from the old IB. The problem is if they have the money support (grant) maybe a nudge, nudge in a constructive direction may help (if allowed).

    A minor story, when my father was a transport driver … he was driving a jeep on a dirt road in France; suddenly he noticed the road before him was spitting dirt. He slammed on the brakes and tumbled into the road side ditch.

    Hope Marion has recovered from her journey.

  14. As a child I spent some time in Shetland and I had never heard about the Shetlan Bus –they never even mentioned it in school!

    Eagle on a diet – never thought about that one!!

    I see nothing in the mail you sent as being negative – being negative is a comment I left (as did someone else) on 365 Lewis blog.

    PS How do I get smileys? [just type them Taddoe]

  15. You might have been told that on Island Blogging Taddoe but I’m not there any longer (nor are you!). So if you have something to say, you should say so. As the locals would say in Languedoc, think: “Liberté, Egalité, Fraternité”. **

    Negativity has its, er, negative aspects but it can also be a power for good when channeled with good intent and in general air of support. That some people elect to interpret it as mischief making is their problem, and generally due to small-mindedness. I think you know what I’m referring to here.

    As I highlighted right at the start of my email to Shetland Amenity Trust, my comments were intended to be taken as constructive and made in a spirit of warmth from an interested party. If they have chosen to take them as negative (which might explain why I have yet to receive a reply, who knows?), then there’s not a lot I can do about it unfortunately.

    Unless of course Mirlnlass can press some buttons locally on my behalf!!

    ** Remove the accents and those words look very strange indeed: “Liberte, Egalite, Fraternite”. Is an ‘egalite’ an eagle on a diet? 🙂

  16. Good post(as usual 4X) I find it a bit sad and strange that shetland doesn’t give more information about it.,but there again i am writing about something that doesn’t really concern me— I have been told to “kindly stop making negative comments regarding scottish islands,so will say no more!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s